4 months ago
2
The Election Commission (EC) of India said galore instances of “logical discrepancies” recovered successful the electoral rotation of West Bengal defies science.
Two electors were recovered with much than 200 children, 7 with much than a 100 children, 10 with much than 50 children portion different 10 with much than 40.
“Some electors are linked with unusually precocious numbers of children… Many specified instances are scientifically intolerable to entertain arsenic valid mapping,” the EC states successful an affidavit to the Supreme Court connected the behaviour of the West Bengal Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exercise.
‘Mapping’ is the method word being utilized by the EC to nexus an elector’s lineage with the 2002 roll. The EC said it has decided that cases successful which six oregon much person mapped themselves to 1 idiosyncratic merited “greater scrutiny arsenic regards validity of linkage”.
The EC affidavit shows that 4,59,054 instances person been recovered with electors having much than 5 children. The fig of electors with much than six children are 2,06,056 successful West Bengal.
“In 2019-2021, arsenic per the NFHS-5 survey, the mean household size successful India is 4.4. This denotes that connected an average, each household consists of two-three children. However, successful immoderate cases, the fig of electors linked to 1 genitor is much than 50,” the EC, represented by elder advocator Rakesh Dwivedi and advocator Eklavya Dwivedi, noted.
A 50-year spread betwixt parents and children person besides been flagged arsenic a logical discrepancy. The EC reasoned that the fertility complaint for women becomes negligible aft 45 years of age.
The EC vehemently objected to disapproval by petitioners that “logical discrepancies” was conscionable different caller class recovered to disenfranchise electors.
“Discovery of a logical discrepancy simply leads to issuance of announcement for the purposes of verification. The notices volition person to clarify the discrepancy and/or nutrient indispensable documents to the restitution of the Electoral Registration Officer (ERO).
The EC denied “field reports” claimed by petitioners, including Trinamool Congress enactment leaders specified arsenic Dola Sen, that affected voters were women electors and minorities and that 90% of the cases were relatable to “failure of the algorithm”.
The affidavit elaborate that draught rolls published connected December 16, 2025 saw the exclusion of 58 lakh voters connected relationship of their absence, death, imperishable shifting of mean residence and duplication of entries. The EC said these exclusions ought not beryllium considered arsenic “deletions”.
The canvass assemblage said “non-inclusion” successful the draught rotation was preceded by house-to-house survey. Those excluded would beryllium fixed an accidental of hearings. There were nary “centralised software-based deletions from the electoral roll”.
The SIR was conducted with the assistance of 80681 BLOs, 7000+ AEROs, 294 EROs and 4000+ micro-observers successful West Bengal. The announcement signifier had started connected December 16, 2025 and would proceed till February 7, 2026.
“The linkage with erstwhile SIR electoral rolls is done manually to guarantee that each electors having linkage with the erstwhile SIR electoral rolls are segregated for inclusion successful the last electoral roll. Those who cannot beryllium linked are issued notices. Upon issuance of notice, successful lawsuit the elector has been erroneously near out, helium oregon she tin furnish the extract of linkage with the erstwhile electoral roll, and successful that event, his oregon her sanction is bound to beryllium included successful the last electoral roll,” the EC clarified.
The EC underscored that lone mappings recovered to beryllium incorrect oregon suffering from sedate irregularities and not linked to electoral rotation of 2002 would beryllium scrutinised.
The EC further clarified that WhatsApping instructions oregon conveying them done video-conferencing was undeniably a speedy means of communication.
“Nothing showing that instructions issued done integer mode are successful struggle with SIR,” the EC said, countering submissions that specified practices dented transparency. The EC powerfully objected to the beingness of governmental parties’ Booth Level Agents (BLAs) astatine the verification hearings earlier the BLAs.
“Hearings are quasi-judicial and lone for the persons concerned. Presence of BLAs successful the hearings would beryllium obstructive and the proceeding process would beryllium delayed unnecessarily. There are six nationalist parties and 2 State parties successful West Bengal… Presence of 8 BLAs successful the proceeding betwixt the ERO and the prospective elector would crook chaotic, considering the charged atmosphere,” the EC reasoned.
The Supreme Court is scheduled to perceive the lawsuit connected January 21.
