6 months ago
1
In a alleviation to Energy Minister K.J. George, the High Court of Karnataka connected Tuesday quashed the transgression proceedings initiated against him and 2 officials connected a ailment lodged by BJP leaders alleging a bid of illegalities and corruption successful the process of awarding tender successful favour of a backstage institution to proviso astute energy meters astatine an exorbitant price.
Justice M.I. Arun passed the bid portion allowing the abstracted petitions filed by Mr. George, Mahantesh Bilagi, past managing manager (MD) of Bangalore Electricity Supply Company (Bescom) and presently MD of Karnataka Minerals Corporation Ltd., and Ramesh H.J., director-technical of Bescom.
The petitioners had questioned the legality of an order, passed connected July 23, by the Special Court of Sessions for transgression cases against erstwhile and contiguous MPs and MLAs, directing the Superintendent of Police (SP), Lokayukta, to taxable a study connected the ailment lodged by the BJP legislators, C.N. Ashwath Narayan, S.R. Vishwanath, and Dheeraj Muniraj.
‘No criminality’
“The tender being awarded successful favour of the palmy bidder, nary criminality tin beryllium attributed against them successful the awarding of the contract,” the tribunal said.
“The mode successful which the tender has been floated and the presumption and conditions of the declaration are mentioned, astatine the maximum the aforesaid tin beryllium challenged to beryllium successful usurpation of the KTPP Act, but decidedly nary criminality tin beryllium attributed to the petitioners.” the High Court observed.
‘Can beryllium a PIL’
However, the tribunal made it wide that the allegations of the provisions of the Karnataka Transparency successful Public Procurements Act, 1999 (KTPP Act) being violated oregon immoderate different improper method of tender process and awarding of the contract, whitethorn springiness emergence to a civilian origin of action, for the acrophobic parties, who were desirous of making a bid for the declaration oregon it tin besides beryllium a substance of nationalist involvement litigation”.
On going done the complaint, the High Court pointed retired that “it is not the lawsuit of the complainants that the petitioners took wealth astatine the clip of awarding the declaration to the palmy bidder. But it is their [of complainants] lawsuit that the full tender process was designed to favour the palmy bidder... which is simply a ammunition institution and beforehand of Mr. George truthful that helium gets unjustly enriched”.
The High Court pointed retired that cipher was illegally disqualified from tender... “and enactment of bidders was made transparently and nary favour has been shown to the palmy bidder”, Rajashree Electricals Pvt. Ltd., (REPL), Davangere.
The tribunal stated that it is not the lawsuit of the complainants that aft finalising the presumption and conditions of the tender document, erstwhile the declaration was awarded to the palmy bidder, the presumption and conditions of the tender papers were altered oregon flouted to favour the palmy bidder. In fact, the Bescom has subsequently negotiated with the palmy bidder to the presumption much favourably to the Bescom.
“...after the tender was awarded to the palmy bidder, negotiations person taken spot and nary further payment has been fixed to the palmy bidder. Whatever changes person taken spot are for the payment of the State oregon arsenic a earthy effect of the concern transactions, for which nary criminality tin beryllium attributed to the accused,” the High Court observed.
