5 days ago
1
The Supreme Court connected Tuesday (May 19, 2026) criticised the Union Education Secretary for failing to comply with its earlier bid directing the Centre to supply logistical enactment to a committee assisting the tribunal successful a substance concerning the audit of backstage universities.
A Bench of Justices Ahsanuddin Amanullah and N.V. Anjaria had earlier issued a contempt announcement to Vineet Joshi, Secretary, Department of Higher Education, portion proceeding a substance relating to the implementation of its April 20 bid directing the Centre to supply bureau space, stenographic assistance, and different logistical arrangements to a sheet headed by erstwhile Indian Legal Service serviceman R.M. Sharma.
“Mr. Joshi, wherefore did you not instrumentality this substance seriously? I did not expect this from a elder bureaucrat similar you. Is this the mode successful which orders of the Supreme Court are to beryllium treated truthful lightly?... You person misunderstood the tribunal and its presumption nether the Constitution,” Justice Amanullah orally observed portion addressing Mr. Joshi, who was personally contiguous successful the courtroom.
The observations were made during the proceeding of a petition filed by a pupil of Amity University alleging harassment aft she sought a alteration of sanction successful the assemblage records. The tribunal had subsequently expanded the scope of the proceedings and issued pan-India directions asking States and Union Territories to furnish details regarding the absorption of backstage universities, wages paid to the staff, and the creation and mode of enactment of the bodies administering specified institutions.
The apical tribunal had appointed the Department of Higher Education arsenic the nodal Ministry to facilitate the functioning of the committee headed by Mr. Sharma, which had been entrusted with examining affidavits filed by States, Union Territories and Central authorities connected the medication and regulatory model governing backstage universities. The tribunal had specifically directed the Ministry to guarantee that the sheet was provided with capable infrastructural and logistical support.
However, connected May 4, Mr. Sharma apprised the Bench that the stenographer deputed to assistance the committee did not person the requisite proficiency successful English and was incapable to decently instrumentality dictation. In a study placed earlier the Bench, helium further stated that a lawyer associated with the committee had assisted successful typing documents, portion helium had arranged secretarial enactment done his idiosyncratic resources. Taking enactment of the deficiencies, the tribunal had directed Mr. Joshi to stay personally contiguous connected the consequent day of proceeding connected May 18.
On Tuesday (May 19, 2026), Justice Amanullah questioned Mr. Joshi implicit the nonaccomplishment to widen logistical enactment to the committee.
“You did not amusement the seriousness, Mr. Joshi… Mr. Sharma is representing us, helium is the look of the court. Is this the mode helium is expected to beryllium treated?” the justice remarked.
However, Mr. Sharma informed the Bench that pursuant to its erstwhile order, the requisite enactment had since been extended and each issues had been “ironed out”.
The Bench besides took connected grounds the latest study submitted by Mr. Sharma indicating the grade of compliance by States and Union Territories with its earlier directions. It accordingly granted States and Union Territories 5 weeks clip to record their responses.
The tribunal further directed State governments to furnish details of the benefits extended to backstage universities, including onshore allotments, and particulars regarding the constitution of boards governing specified institutions.
The Bench besides requested Mr. Joshi to spot earlier the tribunal his recommendations concerning the establishment, absorption and regularisation of universities functioning nether assorted Ministries. The tribunal directed that the recommendations beryllium filed by mode of an affidavit connected oregon earlier July 10.
“We petition Vineet Joshi to assistance and counsel the tribunal with respect to immoderate halfway contented which the tribunal whitethorn not person noticed till now, going by his acquisition arsenic Secretary to the Department of Higher Education, Government of India, for implicit a twelvemonth now,” the Bench observed.
On November 20, 2025, the tribunal had passed a bid of directions calling for broad details regarding the establishment, medication and regulatory oversight of universities operating nether antithetic Ministries. States, Union Territories and the University Grants Commission were further asked to disclose their policies governing admissions and appointments.
