6 months ago
2
The opening time of the autumn league of J&K Assembly witnessed heated exchanges during obituary references, arsenic the National Conference and the absorption BJP traded barbs implicit the relation of erstwhile Governor precocious Satya Pal Malik successful the abrogation of Article 370 successful 2019.
The sanction of Malik — the 10th and past Governor of the erstwhile State of Jammu and Kashmir who passed distant successful August this twelvemonth — triggered a enactment aft National Conference (NC) MLA Bashir Veeri termed his relation controversial, with BJP subordinate Sham Lal Sharma demanding the remarks beryllium expunged.
Speaker Abdul Rahim Rather, portion asking Mr. Veeri to respect the deceased, did not judge Mr. Sharma's request to expunge the NC MLA's remarks.
However, astatine the decision of the obituary references, Chief Minister Omar Abdullah said Malik indispensable person acted with the content that helium was doing good.
Congress legislative enactment person G A Mir, however, called Malik a bully leader, who was "outspoken" and "popular".
"He mightiness person benefitted from it (Article 370 abrogation), but helium suffered arsenic well. We saw however helium had to conflict successful his past days to enactment the information earlier the people," Mir said.
PDP MLA Rafiq Naik said portion determination whitethorn beryllium differences with Malik, "we should not talk negatively portion paying tributes to the deceased".
"We whitethorn person differences, but since helium (Malik) has near us, we should talk bully of him," helium said.
Mr. Naik besides raised the contented of AAP MLA Mehraj Malik, who was arrested past period nether the Public Safety Act for allegedly disturbing nationalist bid successful Doda district, but the talker said, "You are speaking connected obituary references, and helium (Mehraj Malik) is inactive alive".
On Satya Pal Malik, CPI(M) MLA M.Y. Tarigami said obituary does not mean "we bash not larn a lesson".
"Respect apart, a idiosyncratic who was entrusted with a nationalist work should besides beryllium assessed for his actions. Otherwise, it becomes a regular exercise. Even disapproval tin beryllium done by staying wrong the levels of decency," Mr. Tarigami said.
Awami Ittehad Party MLA Sheikh Khursheed said portion constructive disapproval should beryllium allowed, Satya Pal Malik was the past politician of J&K, who aboriginal raised farmers' issues and was an honorable politician.
Asserting that August 5, 2019, was a historical time (when Article 370 was abrogated), BJP's Vikram Randhawa, portion referring to Satya Pal Malik, said an mean idiosyncratic cannot beryllium made the politician of 5 states.
"The BJP saw his endowment and appointed him (as governor). August 5 is simply a historical time for J-K, and it was a coincidence that Satya Pal Malik breathed his past connected August 5 (this year)," Mr. Randhawa said.
The remarks led to protests by immoderate NC MLAs, with Nazir Gurezi claiming that Malik did “some unconstitutional things” which volition beryllium written successful history.
However, BJP MLA Narinder Singh said the recognition for achieving 'One Nation, One Constitution' goes to Malik.
Deputy Chief Minister Surinder Choudhary, meanwhile, said anyone who comes from extracurricular J-K, beryllium it a politician oregon an IAS oregon an IPS officer, writes an autobiography aft his/her retirement.
“I privation they constitute it portion they are here. A antheral who occupied aggregate law posts, would it not beryllium due that helium beryllium draped successful the tricolour aft his death,” helium asked.
Leader of Opposition Sunil Sharma said the members should not accidental thing against those who person near this world.
“None of these persons would person thought that someday a subordinate sitting successful this House would accidental things successful a antithetic way. The aforesaid tin hap to america tomorrow. How volition the household consciousness then? We should beryllium mindful of that,” Mr. Sharma said.
Echoing the sentiment, Chief Minister Abdullah said everyone makes mistakes, knowingly oregon unknowingly.
"None of america is an angel sent by God. We person besides made mistakes,” helium said.
Paying tributes to the deceased leaders, Mr. Abdullah said helium had a accidental to enactment with immoderate of them.
“Some of them I ne'er met. But each 1 of them tried to bash thing good. All of them served radical either done elections oregon done governmental parties.
"Today these radical person near us, and we volition besides permission (the world) immoderate day. When? No 1 knows. But 1 happening is definite that we each person to go. The House and its members volition retrieve us," Mr. Abdullah said.
Referring to Satya Pal Malik, the Chief Minister said helium served arsenic an MLA, an MP, a Minister astatine the Centre, and past arsenic a governor.
“When past volition beryllium written, everyone volition beryllium mentioned. We would similar to judge that helium did immoderate helium did with the volition of doing good,” Mr. Abdullah added.
Earlier, the Speaker expressed displeasure implicit the information that the lawman commissioners of respective districts did not respond to requests for accusation astir immoderate erstwhile legislators who mightiness person passed distant since the erstwhile league of the Assembly.
The Speaker besides expressed dissatisfaction that the lawman commissioner of Kupwara responded to the petition by saying determination was nary specified deaths, adjacent though the erstwhile MLA from Langate successful the district, Mohammad Sultan Pandithpori, passed distant successful May.
Commenting connected the miss, Mr. Abdullah said, “House proceedings should not beryllium taken lightly." The main curate besides projected to bash distant with obituary references by idiosyncratic members, saying lone the talker should work them to prevention time.
“On this day, fto america marque a resoluteness to enactment successful a caller way. The process was the aforesaid successful Parliament, but idiosyncratic felt that it was a discarded of time.
"Now, the talker reads the obituary references and the House stands arsenic a people of respect. May beryllium we should besides bash the same.
"The champion tribute would beryllium to not discarded clip and get consecutive to work. This is my suggestion, the remainder is up to you (Speaker) arsenic you are custodian of the House,” Mr. Abdullah said.
He added, “Being politicians, sometimes we marque governmental statements. To debar this, we should travel the Parliament." Stating that determination was substance successful the suggestion, Rather assured to instrumentality up the matter.
The House observed a two-minute soundlessness arsenic a people of respect for the departed leaders, which besides included ex-minister Gulchain Singh Charak, erstwhile MLA Dina Nath Bhagat, ex-MLCs Ghulam Nabi Shaheen, Ramesh Arora and Sardar Mohammad Akhlaq Khan.
The Speaker past adjourned the House till Monday (October 27, 2025).
