8 months ago
3
In January 2006, I stayed astatine Kashmir House successful Islamabad’s posh F-5 Sector, a neighbourhood of wide avenues framed by hills, a uncommon show for a South Asian capital. Having spent overmuch of my assemblage beingness astatine Delhi University visiting Kashmir House successful Chanakyapuri, I could not assistance but announcement the contrast. In New Delhi, the compound was lined with ageing Ambassador cars, portion successful Islamabad the governmental elite showcased their clout with fleets of Pajeros, SUVs that were inactive a rarity successful South Asia astatine the time. When I remarked connected this to 1 of my hosts, a young writer from Bagh, situated successful cardinal Pakistan occupied Jammu and Kashmir (POJK) and based successful Islamabad, helium quipped that it was the “Pajero culture” that ruled the region, a telling reflection of the elitism that has agelong defined its politics.
For decades, the Pakistani authorities has diplomatically showcased Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir (POJK) to the satellite arsenic if it were a abstracted country, implicit with its ain constitution, a Prime Minister arsenic main executive, and a President arsenic law head. In existent practice, the divers governmental portion of Jammu and Kashmir that came unneurotic due to the fact that of a confluence of galore factors successful the 19th century, has propounded galore myths. One specified story relates to POJK, a sliver of the undivided princely authorities that has been controlled by Pakistan since 1947, which has often escaped fashionable discussion. Pakistan refers to this country arsenic “Azad Jammu and Kashmir”, meaning autarkic Jammu and Kashmir. Its legislative assembly has the powerfulness to elite its premier curate and president. At planetary fora, the nomenclature of enforcement positions and a abstracted Constitution are presented arsenic grounds by Pakistan that the portion is an autarkic entity. However, the world is simply a batch different.
Global spotlight connected the territory
Yet, the caller convulsive developments successful the portion person erstwhile again turned the planetary spotlight connected the territory, underscoring the nonaccomplishment of a governmental operation devoid of accountability and transparency to the section people. According to autarkic sources, astatine slightest eleven protesters and 3 policemen person been killed successful days of clashes, adjacent arsenic the authorities urges demonstrators to instrumentality to dialogue. There is connection blackout successful the region. The protests are being spearheaded by the Jammu Kashmir Joint Awami Action Committee (JKJAAC), which has mobilised astir demands for ending peculiar allowances to authorities officials and securing subsidised energy and wheat, arsenic provided successful different parts of Pakistan. The JKJAAC enactment accuses authorities of reneging connected promises. Its leaders gully members from traders, transporters, lawyers, students, and different grassroots groups. Formally established astir September 2023, it emerged arsenic a cross-regional level to transmission extended nationalist discontent implicit economical misgovernance, inequities, and the attraction of powerfulness successful elite circles. JKJAAC’s demands autumn broadly into 2 interlinked categories: contiguous economical alleviation and structural/constitutional reforms.
The JKJAAC has called for contiguous economical alleviation successful the signifier of subsidised energy and wheat prices, connected a par with different regions of Pakistan. It besides demands the removal of elite perks and privileges for Ministers and bureaucrats, alongside escaped and equitable entree to acquisition and wellness care. Longer-term reforms see judicial and governance restructuring arsenic good arsenic improved infrastructure, including the constitution of an airport. Beyond economical relief, the JKJAAC has besides pressed for structural reforms, including the abolition of 12 reserved “refugee seats” successful the POJK Legislative Assembly, wide viewed arsenic a instrumentality of Islamabad’s control. It besides calls for a simplification successful the size of the executive, the rollback of elite perks and bureaucratic privileges, and guarantees that section communities payment from POJK’s hydropower and earthy resources. Finally, the question seeks the elimination of quota-based allocations that disadvantage the region’s residents.
In the caller convulsive protests, JKJAAC leaders assertion that astatine slightest 11 protesters person been killed and much than 200 injured; “all suffering gunshot wounds.” These claims, however, person been denied by the authorities, who importune that their offers to conscionable the demands person been ignored. Officials assertion that astir 90% of the demands were accepted during talks, including energy and section authorities reforms, and withdrawal of protestation cases. Rejecting this, JKJAAC person Syed Hafeez Hamdani, successful a written statement, asserted: “The assertion that our demands person been accepted is contrary to the facts… If our demands had been accepted, we would person had nary crushed to support protesting.” In reality, the protests are not simply astir section grievances; they bespeak the deeper structural power exercised by Islamabad done law provisions that person agelong shaped the uneasy narration betwixt Islamabad and Muzaffarabad since 1947. This layered history, with each its nuances, is often reduced to a simplistic binary. As a result, immoderate critique of the strategy is excessively readily dismissed arsenic “India-sponsored.”
Political request for abolition of exile seats
At the bosom of the existent stalemate is the governmental request for the abolition of exile seats. The Prime Minister of POJK Chaudhry Anwar ul Haq has openly acknowledged that “there is simply a deadlock connected the seats of the refugees, which cannot extremity successful the discourse of the Kashmir movement.” To recognize wherefore these seats person go specified a flashpoint, the contented indispensable beryllium examined done a humanities and law lens. The POJK Constitution reserves 12 of the 45 elected “general” Assembly seats for those who migrated from the Indian broadside of Jammu and Kashmir successful 1947 and aboriginal settled crossed Pakistan. In practice, however, these constituencies correspond Pakistani citizens with small transportation to POJK’s regular realities. Strikingly, 9 of these 12 seats are located not successful POJK astatine each but crossed Punjab, portion the remaining 3 are successful Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Balochistan, and Sindh. This statement has provided Islamabad with a nonstop and often decisive lever of power implicit the Assembly and, by extension, POJK’s governmental landscape.
The larger demographic representation down this allocation and organisation of the 12 seats is that refugees who arrived from Kashmir and Jammu, 2 culturally, ethnically and linguistically chiseled provincial units, person been allotted six seats each. However, connected the ground, this allocation and their organisation has resulted successful an absurdity successful presumption of practice arsenic successful 1947, migration from the Kashmir vale was minimal.
Reportedly, successful the 2021 election, 3,73,652 [3.73 lakh] were registered successful the six constituencies representing the refugees from Jammu, whereas lone 29,804 (just 7%) were registered successful the six constituencies representing the refugees from Kashmir valley. In 1947, astir 80% of migrants from the Indian broadside of Jammu and Kashmir settled successful Pakistani Punjab, not POJK. Several factors contributed to this phenomenon. Most migration occurred from the Jammu plains, geographically person to the Sialkot territory and culturally akin to the Punjab province. Compared to POJK, Punjab offered much economical opportunities for migrant communities.
Economist Mehboob-ul-Haq, the creator of the acclaimed Human Development Index, universally accepted arsenic a amended alternate to Gross Domestic Product arsenic the measurement of a nation’s prosperity, was a Jammu migrant. Pakistan’s famed pistillate singer, Malika Pukhraj, who migrated to Lahore during the 1947 riots, was calved successful the Hamirpur Sidhar colony adjacent Akhnoor successful Jammu. In fact, the bulk of Muslim migration was from the Dogri and Punjabi speaking Jammu plains of Jammu province. Even earlier 1947, a important information of the colonisation surviving connected the Jammu plains, Muslims arsenic good arsenic Hindus, was tied to neighbouring parts of Punjab province, present successful Pakistan, due to the fact that of family, trade, acquisition and employment. The geography played its portion arsenic from Jammu city, the wintertime superior of Jammu and Kashmir, large Pakistani cities specified arsenic Sialkot and Lahore, the superior of Pakistani Punjab, are little than 1 hr and little than 2 hours distant respectively. In contrast, the region betwixt the summertime superior of Jammu and Kashmir, Srinagar, Lahore is astatine slightest 10 to 12 hours away.
As mentioned earlier, adjacent seats, six each, person been allocated for refugees coming from Kashmir state and Jammu state respectively, the 2 culturally, ethnically and linguistically chiseled provincial units of Jammu and Kashmir. However, connected the ground, it results successful absurdity successful presumption of representation. The information of the 2006 Assembly elections uncover that determination were 5,46,031 registered voters for the six seats for Jammu whereas determination were lone 35,256 voters for the six seats reserved for the Kashmir state refugees. Although the fig of seats is the same, the fig of voters from the Kashmir state was lone 0.06% of the full migrant ballot bank. Even wrong the six seats for the Jammu province, the spot of the constituencies is uneven: LA5 and LA6 successful Rawalpindi had 5,000 and 1,50,000 voters respectively. Holding elections for these exile constituencies has small applicable representational and legislative relevance arsenic the descendants of the 1947 migrants are socially and economically well-integrated successful Pakistan, peculiarly Pakistani Punjab.
Past trends and acquisition show that the enactment ruling successful Islamabad is capable to country the bulk of exile seats, giving the enactment ruling Islamabad the vantage successful authorities enactment successful Muzaffarabad, the superior of POJK.
In 1975, Zulfikar Bhutto’s Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) brought down the Muslim Conference authorities connected the spot of these seats. In 1990, the Muslim Conference won each 12 exile seats and Nawaz Sharif, the past Prime Minister, boasted that his authorities had “gifted” these seats to Muslim Conference laminitis and leader, Sardar Qayoom. The signifier replicated successful the 2021 POJK election. The PTI won 75% of the exile seats, compared to 48% of seats successful the remaining 33 elected seats wrong POJK. In December 2007, Sultan Mehmood Chaudhry, presently President of POJK and a jat from Mirpur, had demanded abolition of the 12 seats reserved successful the Assembly for “Kashmiris” settled successful different parts of Pakistan. He had alleged that the “ruling parties successful Pakistan ever manipulate elections for these seats. The holding of elections for Jammu and Kashmir migrants successful assorted parts of Pakistan simply serves arsenic an instrumentality to payment the ruling enactment successful Islamabad. More important, it perpetuates a selective pan-Pakistan societal communicative connected Jammu and Kashmir that consequently limits the scope and quality of the Pakistani State to attack the Kashmir contented and the broader India-Pakistan bid process with realism.
The protesters’ request to extremity elitism gains added urgency successful a strategy wherever organization frameworks alteration elite seizure of cardinal appointments and decision-making. The Islamabad based POJK Council has agelong held authority, ceremonial oregon informal, implicit high-stakes appointments, particularly successful the judiciary, bureaucracy, and law bodies. It has power implicit the enactment of the Chief Election Commissioner (who is appointed by the POJK President connected the proposal of the Chairman of the Council). More broadly, the Council has historically had accidental successful appointments of judges to the High Court and Supreme Court of POJK, often via proposal oregon consultation roles vis-à-vis the President and the national government. In addition, it has wielded power implicit bureaucratic postings wrong the Council Secretariat itself, specified arsenic lawman secretaries, conception officers, and drafting and disbursing officers—appointments that critics reason person often bypassed the jurisdiction of the POJK authorities and been driven by favoritism.
Beyond appointments, the Council’s scope historically extended to administrative oversight and power of departments, fiscal management, and legislative subjects: taxation, earthy resources, tourism, infrastructure, and large improvement schemes person been taxable to Council jurisdiction nether its legislative database of 52 subjects. While the 13th Amendment of the POJK constitution successful 2018 sought to portion galore of these powers and devolve them to the POJK Assembly oregon to Islamabad directly, the structural relation of the Council successful appointments and oversight remains arguable and contested.
POJK often been sidelined
In this setup, the POJK Legislative Assembly, which is elected, has often been sidelined. Even though it is expected to marque laws connected authorities subjects (especially those not reserved for the national side), it lacks comparable powers implicit appointments, large administrative decisions, oregon power implicit law bodies. The Assembly does not name judges oregon law commissioners; those stay nether the Council’s domain (or nether proposal of the Council). Thus, successful practice, portion the Assembly whitethorn statement oregon power argumentation successful its domain, the existent levers of power, from who leads the Election Commission to who occupies elder judicial oregon bureaucratic posts, often prevarication beyond its reach. This structural disparity intensifies the protesters’ critique: adjacent antiauthoritarian institutions specified arsenic the Assembly tin beryllium successful a hollowed form, portion elite executives entrenched successful the Council and national apparatus support decisive control.
The POJK council, though presented arsenic a associated administrative mechanism, has functioned mostly arsenic an instrumentality of power alternatively than self-governance. Its creation itself reflects this imbalance: the Prime Minister of Pakistan serves arsenic its Chairman, with the POJK President arsenic Vice-Chairman, but the bulk of members are appointed by Islamabad.
Out of its 11 members, six are nominated straight by the Government of Pakistan, portion lone 5 are elected by the POJK Legislative Assembly. This operation ensures that decisive power rests with Pakistan’s national authorities, allowing them to steer legislative, financial, and administrative matters successful the territory. Instead of empowering section representatives, the Council has curtailed the authorization of the elected POJK Assembly, keeping cardinal subjects specified arsenic earthy resources, taxation, and important appointments nether the watchful oculus of Islamabad. In effect, the assemblage underscores the world that POJK’s governmental autonomy is limited, with the Council serving arsenic a instrumentality done which the national authorities manages and contains the region.
It is important to item the substance of the protests haven’t crossed oregon challenged the organization redlines of Pakistani authorities connected POJK oregon its broader authoritative stance connected Jammu and Kashmir. For instance, the broader law and procedural contours wrong which elections to the POJK Assembly had been antecedently held demolish the story that the portion is an autarkic entity arsenic Pakistan claims. There are bigger law provisions that contention Pakistan’s authoritative and diplomatic claims, specified arsenic Article 257 of Pakistani constitution, which says, “When the radical of the State of Jammu and Kashmir determine to accede to Pakistan, the narration betwixt Pakistan and the State shall beryllium determined successful accordance with the wishes of the radical of that State.”
On the contrary, Part 2 of Section 7 of the 1974 POJK Constitution says that “no idiosyncratic oregon governmental enactment successful Azad Jammu and Kashmir shall beryllium permitted to propagate against oregon instrumentality portion successful activities prejudicial oregon detrimental to the ideology of the state’s accession to Pakistan.” Section 5(2)(vii) of the POJK Legislative Assembly Election Ordinance, 1970, says a idiosyncratic volition beryllium disqualified for propagating immoderate sentiment oregon enactment successful immoderate mode prejudicial to the ideology of Pakistan, and that the ideology of the state’s accession to Pakistan oregon the sovereignty and integrity of Pakistan. Nobody is allowed to enactment successful the POJK Legislative Assembly predetermination without signing an affidavit pledging allegiance to Jammu and Kashmir’s accession to Pakistan.
In respective polls, respective parties specified arsenic the All Parties Nationalist Alliance (APNA), espousing an autarkic authorities of Jammu and Kashmir, were not allowed to enactment due to the fact that they refused to motion specified an affidavit. Islamabad has the powerfulness to disregard immoderate POJK government. Article 53 of the POJK Constitution gives the national authorities the powerfulness to disregard an elected authorities successful POJK. This proviso is portion of the exigency provisions of the Pakistani Constitution. Therefore, the national authorities enjoys the aforesaid exigency powers implicit POJK arsenic it does implicit immoderate different state of Pakistan. During the regularisation of Pakistan’s archetypal subject leader, Ayub Khan, the president of POJK, K. Khurshid, a uncommon Kashmiri-speaking person successful the portion and backstage caput to Mohammad Ali Jinnah, the archetypal governor-general of Pakistan, was forced to resign by a mid-level constabulary authoritative and aboriginal jailed erstwhile helium started espousing his views successful public, which were successful absorption to Pakistani authoritative stance connected J&K.
There is nary uncertainty that protests person agelong punctuated the governmental past of POJK. One specified aboriginal occurrence took spot successful the Sandunti country of Bagh, commonly remembered arsenic the Sudhans rebellion successful the cardinal POJK. The Sudhans, a salient clan successful the region, roseate up successful the aboriginal post-Partition years against what they saw arsenic exclusion from powerfulness and heavy-handed interference by Islamabad. Though localised, the rebellion highlighted simmering resentment implicit unequal representation, economical neglect, and the imposition of authorization from extracurricular the region. Later, successful the 1960s, Mirpur witnessed large-scale protests against the operation of the Mangla Dam, which displaced astir 81,000 radical and acceptable successful question different rhythm of grievances. Their migration has a layered history: the archetypal question came a period ago, erstwhile men from Mirpur and adjacent areas recovered employment arsenic seamen successful Britain, portion the 2nd question followed the Mangla Dam displacements. Migration has since continued unabated, supported by beardown familial connections, and contiguous the diaspora is widespread. After the outbreak of militancy successful the Kashmir Valley successful 1989, militants successful the vale besides relied connected the Mirpuri diaspora for worldly support. That is wherefore the governmental aspirations of this assemblage are not uniform.
That is wherefore 1 needs to beryllium realistic and much attuned to the crushed which are manifested successful geographical, military, sociological and humanities realities. It would beryllium misleading to construe these protests arsenic grounds that POJK is inclined to align with India successful the future. The reasons for the contiguous Line of Control prevarication successful deeper ethnic, geographic, and humanities dynamics. The governmental realities successful POJK successful 1947 were precise antithetic from those of the Kashmir Valley, wherever Sheikh Abdullah’s popularity and his absorption to the two-nation mentation determined the people of history. The portion has a antithetic taste and linguistic basal arsenic compared to Kashmir valley, and is culturally, ethnically and linguistically, much adjacent to adjoining parts of Pakistani Punjab specified arsenic Rawalpindi, Gujrat, Jhelum oregon adjacent Sialkot districts. There are familial and caste ties betwixt the 2 areas.
In cardinal POJK, section Muslims, galore of them ex-servicemen of British Army, roseate successful rebellion against Maharaja Hari Singh, for a big of reasons, a improvement soon reinforced by the tribal penetration launched from the past North-West Frontier Province. Unlike successful the Kashmir Valley, this operation led to the accelerated illness of the Maharaja’s forces and contiguous de facto power of the country by the Pakistani army. Also, the country of POJK is geographically adjacent to the main cities of Pakistan, Islamabad and Lahore. It takes 8 hours to question the nonstop way betwixt Mirpur and Muzaffarabad wrong POJK, whereas passing done Islamabad cuts the travelling clip by half. This is explained by the geography of the hilly portion of POJK. At the aforesaid time, determination is nary uncertainty that determination had been predominant protests against the Pakistani ruling leadership. In the look of these facts, with a renewed attraction connected the portion and arsenic documented successful my publication connected the region, a binary communicative should marque mode for a much nuanced and granular knowing of the facts relating to the portion which are grounded successful the prevailing socio-political realities of the region, including a analyzable law narration with Pakistan, geographic realities, past and a divers acceptable of aspirations of the POJK diaspora.
The “Pajero culture” I observed successful Islamabad astir two-decades agone was not simply astir symbols of wealth. It reflected a deeper elite bid that has agelong shaped authorities successful POJK. The existent protests are not an aberration but a nonstop outgrowth of this entrenched system, wherever privileges, exile seats, and law constraints person ensured Islamabad’s dominance astatine the disbursal of section accountability. What is unfolding contiguous is, therefore, little astir isolated economical grievances and much astir a conflict against a governmental civilization that has denied mean radical successful POJK a meaningful accidental successful their ain future. At the aforesaid time, however, 1 should beryllium cautious not to work excessively overmuch into these developments; the realities stay much complex, rooted successful section governance failures and the peculiar law narration with Islamabad.
(Luv Puri has authored 2 books connected Jammu and Kashmir namely Uncovered Face of Militancy and Across the Line of Control, the second published by Columbia University Press, which was based connected tract enactment successful the region.)
