7 months ago
2
Upnesh Kumar, 79, sums up 3 decades of Bihar authorities successful 3 sentences astir energy proviso to his village.
“During Jaganath Mishra’s clip (December 1989- March 1990) adjacent earlier you could tally the fields aft switching connected the centrifugal the powerfulness would go. In Lalu’s epoch (March 1990-November 2005) each powerfulness lines were down. Under Nitish Kumar (November 2005 onwards) we get 22-23 hours of powerfulness each day,” Mr. Upnesh Kumar said. He is simply a kurmi, the aforesaid caste arsenic Chief Minister Nitish Kumar.
At the extremity of 2 decades successful power, Mr. Nitish Kumar remains the centrepiece of Bihar politics. But this predetermination is much astir the question: is it Mr. Nitish Kumar’s swansong oregon does helium person different symphony near successful him.
It has been a agelong travel for him. In 1977 astatine the crest of the anti-Congress question galore young socialist leaders briskly rode to Parliament, but Nitish mislaid the elections by 5,895 votes, sticking retired arsenic an unusual 1 among his socialist colleagues. He did nary amended the 2nd clip around. In the 1980 Assembly polls, helium was defeated again. It was lone successful his 3rd outing successful 1985 Assembly elections that helium yet tasted victory. He was ne'er again without a spot successful a legislature. Since 1995, Harnaut has been with the Samata enactment and past the Janata Dal (United).
Bihar’s economical improvement has been chequered. Mr. Nitish Kumar is credited for his administrative acumen, yet determination is statistical grounds often cited by his opponents to underline his failures.
In effect to a question by JD(U) MP Giridhari Yadav successful the past session, the Parliament was told that arsenic per the provisional estimates released connected May 30, 2025, the per capita Net National Income is ₹2,05,324, portion that of Bihar is ₹69,321. Bihar’s stock of nationalist GDP besides remains little than 3 per cent. In 1960-61 agreed Bihar was astatine 7.8 % — 4th highest successful the country. On split, with Jharkhand being carved out, it came down to 2.8% successful 2000-01 and has remained stagnant successful the aforesaid fig successful 2023-24 arsenic per the Economic Advisory Council to the PM’s September 2024 study connected “Relative Economic Performance of Indian States.”
These statistic chopped small crystal successful Harnaut wherever the neat tree-lined roads, regular h2o and powerfulness supply, are seen arsenic amended markers for the elusive “vikas” (development) that politicians speech astir but the voters seldom get to see.
Mr. Upnesh Kumar’s neighbour Ashutosh Kumar (65), besides a kurmi, chimes in. “There is nary 1 who is arsenic trustworthy arsenic him successful immoderate party, BJP included.” helium said. The speculation astir his declining intelligence acuity and BJP’s machinations to propulsion him retired of the Chief Minister’s chair, is earning him sympathy of the electorate here.
Two complaints
Nitish’s untainted persona is hailed; but determination are 2 communal complaints — the increasing dominance of bureaucracy and the JD(U) legislators. JD(U) dropped lone 4 of its sitting legislators.
Kalyan Bigha is Mr. Nitish Kumar’s ancestral village. Here his two-storey location stands adjacent to the colony pond. An unadorned structure, that bears nary distinguishing marks of its owner. A padlock hangs from the brownish woody door. The windows are shuttered. The location stands aloof, overmuch similar its owner.
Pappu Thakur, who belongs to Nai assemblage listed arsenic Extremely Backward Community, has a store other to the Chief Minister’s home. He is simply a men’s tailor. His eyes are trained connected the cloth successful hand, helium measures, marks, and cuts it utilizing a dense robust scissor, without erstwhile pausing portion simultaneously delivering an appraisal of the Nitish government. His ballot remains for the JD(U), aft all, if not for the infrastructure that Nitish authorities built, helium argues, could helium person returned, aft surviving successful Mumbai for 21 years. But helium is not an uncomplaining voter. Nitish visits his location thrice successful twelvemonth to wage respect to his deceased parents and wife, each clip helium comes successful a cordon of bureaucrats and police. A phantom, unseen and unheard by his ain villagers, helium laments. He is aggravated that the JD(U) didn’t alteration Harnaut’s MLA Harinarayan Singh, who has been successful the spot since 2010.
The electorate could person done with a caller look and younger candidate, helium says. Harnaut has been a battleground of the JD(U) vs Lok Janshakti Party. For the past 3 elections it has been a nonstop contention betwixt the two. For the archetypal time, the 2 parties are connected the aforesaid side, allowing the Congress which has fielded to instrumentality the abstraction of challenger here.
In the Nalanda constituency, wherever Rural Development Minister and JD(U) person Sharwan Kumar is successful fray, voters mention akin complaints. At a beverage shop, Lav Kumar Mishra, Chandrakant Prasad, a Kurmi, and P.K. Verma, a Chandravanshi, are sipping the evening cupful of beverage successful tiny kulhads. Mr. Mishra, the astir vocal of the three, begins the conversation. Chandravanshi falls successful the Extremely Backward Category. “Sharwan Kumar wins lone due to the fact that helium is contesting from the JD(U), different helium would not triumph a panchayat election,” helium declares. The different 2 motion successful agreement. Their ailment is that helium is moving done “agents” successful villages, disconnected from the populace. While Mr. Mishra takes the adjacent measurement declaring that helium volition ballot for the Jan Suraj Party this time, simply due to the fact that helium is anxious to spot change, the different 2 don’t agree. “Prashant Kisor is untested. Nitish Kumar is tested and trusted,” Mr. Verma said.
In Nalanda for present it is Mr. Nitish Kumar.
