3 months ago
1
Iranian filmmaker-activist Mahnaz Mohammadi, 51, lets maine grounds her connected camera, astatine the 76th Berlin International Film Festival, wherever her sophomore feature Roya premiered successful the Panorama segment. She says she loves Indians. An Indian person had talented her a clock, whose clip she didn’t change. Now, that frozen clip acts similar a bully memory. Life is simply a bid of fragments that flits betwixt representation and forgetting, the conscious and unconscious. And that too, is the operation of her caller film.
The Women Without Shadows (2003) manager is known for her documentary films. Mohammadi, aft her Toronto-premiered debut feature Son-Mother (2019), has been banned by Iran from making films. Her progressive engagement successful Campaign for Equality (aka One Million Signatures Campaign), 2006, to request changes to discriminatory laws against Iranian women, enactment her successful the enactment of fire, with the Iranian authorities persecuting and arresting her multiples times, successful 2007, 2009, 2011, and successful 2014 for 5 years successful Tehran’s Evin Prison. Also an actor, she is simply a taste dependable that confronts censorship, sex inequality, and state of look successful Iran. Her profoundly humanistic films focuses not connected authorities for its ain involvement but connected lived experiences nether repression, giving dependable to those silenced by the system, by the Iranian regime.
In her latest film, changeable clandestinely, featuring a Turkish actress, Roya is an Iranian teacher who is imprisoned successful Tehran’s Evin Prison for her governmental beliefs and is faced with a choice: either to marque a forced televised confession oregon stay confined to her 3-sq.m cell. As past and contiguous gaffe retired of series and speech places, she moves betwixt interior landscapes and lived experience, revealing however isolation tin reshape perception, identity, and the fragile anticipation of resistance.
After galore years of moving with documentary forms, she returns to communicative cinema, albeit non-linear, her sophomore diagnostic doesn’t effort to reproduce world but presents a dialog betwixt cognition and memory. Dualities of imagination and reality, past and contiguous blur. For trauma, representation doesn’t determination successful a consecutive line. Resistance is not opposing a force, but refusing to disappear.
Excerpts from a roundtable interview:
You person a Turkish histrion effort the relation of Roya, not an Iranian actress. Was it done to support identities since you made the movie secretly?
When I’m looking for the quality truthful important for me, it takes truthful overmuch time. I was definite I didn’t privation to find an Iranian face, which has been seen successful galore Iranian films. Their communicative is successful the net everywhere, and they are losing their mystery. When you are watching, you retrieve their ain idiosyncratic communicative earlier watching the film. Even for my erstwhile film, Son-Mother (2019), I chose not the look of an actor. But [Turkish actress] Melisa [Sözen] is an astonishing planetary actor. After prison, for astir 2 years, I couldn’t spell out. A fewer friends came home. I watched a movie done 1 of their suggestions. It was a infinitesimal erstwhile I was watching [Nuri Bilge Ceylan’s] Winter Sleep (2014). I saw Melisa’s quality nether suppression. I felt I recognize her, and I started crying.
For the archetypal 20 minutes, we spot the dark, claustrophobic innards of the situation satellite from the non-linear position of the titular Roya. We spot humor connected the level and a restricted presumption of everything. How did you determine connected this signifier and structure?
For me, it was always, ‘I don’t privation to explicate [the story], I don’t privation to speech astir what they did with me’. I person to find a mode to springiness this accidental to the assemblage to person a travel with Roya. Roya successful Persian means dream. I’m inviting the assemblage to person this imagination together, to acquisition Roya’s world, wherever world and unreality merge. Not by separating Roya’s cognition of past and present, due to the fact that she doesn’t cognize what is the certainty of everything, what is the truth. The assemblage permission with Roya astatine the aforesaid time. I’m not guiding the assemblage connected however they should feel. The storytelling is based connected the unconscious operation successful your dreams. Look astatine 1 of your dreams, you’ll retrieve immoderate pictures and immoderate noises without immoderate meanings. I wished to marque a movie whose ending should not beryllium similar its beginning.
Looking backmost astatine the clip erstwhile you were charged blameworthy and arrested, person you seen anticipation alteration from past to now?
I’m ever hopeful. At that time, erstwhile I wrote that [open] missive (during post-election unrest), successful 2009, it was conscionable my situation. I’m a woman, I’m a filmmaker, I’m guilty, but present it’s not ‘I’, it’s ‘we’. And unfortunately, truthful galore countries didn’t spot our pain. They didn’t perceive to our voices that tin nary longer carnivore to enactment oregon header with this system, the Islamic Republic. We conscionable became portion of the system’s property. In 2009, I wrote this, but who listened? Nobody. Now ‘I’ became ‘we’. We are guilty. We don’t person a close to unrecorded successful Iran. People wrong Iran are warring for survival. And, inactive I person hope. During the war, everybody was talking astir Gaza and each the Leftists now, they are quiet. It means erstwhile the radical don’t travel your ideology, you don’t attraction astir them. Just ticker Doctors Without Borders (Médecins Sans Frontières), they didn’t adjacent springiness a paragraph to each who died: the doctors, nurses. What does it mean?
Can cinema alteration anything?
Cinema can’t alteration anything. Cinema can’t bring the justice. Cinema tin bring consciousness to the people’s decision, and erstwhile the people’s cognition changes, possibly thing gets changed.
A inactive from ‘Roya’ | Photo Credit: @Pak Film
At this festival, planetary assemblage subordinate Wim Wenders said cinema is the counterweight to politics. Politics has remained the subtext of Iranian cinema, albeit its look has evolved, from speaking done children to nonstop realism. Can films and authorities beryllium separated?
Maybe, sometimes. Sometimes misunderstanding oregon misconception volition happen. I tin archer you, I’m not making governmental films. Not astatine all. But the concern the radical are surviving in, I couldn’t disregard it. Even present successful Iran, the briefing of going to the thoroughfare aft six o’clock has go portion of the activism, due to the fact that everyplace determination are truthful galore radical being arrested, being killed truly easily. How tin I disagreement it betwixt this and that. I don’t privation to marque a movie astir that but I privation to marque the movie astir what happened aft each those authorities suppress the people.
What does it mean to marque films clandestinely? Jafar Panahi has done it. He’s been sentenced to a twelvemonth successful situation by Iran now. Do you spot cinema arsenic a signifier of absorption to the authorities prohibition connected artists. What astir courageousness would you archer young women filmmakers successful Iran?
When you’re moving successful this way, your hands are cuffed. You’re putting people’s beingness successful danger. It’s not casual astatine all, and each the clip you person to beryllium truthful flexible, truthful acceptable for immoderate alteration but, still, it’s the lone mode to survive. When for truthful galore years, you are nether the suppression, to defy not to beryllium portion of those lies, it was my practice. They enactment maine successful the situation to not to survive, financially and mentally. I was looking for the information but couldn’t find it, everybody has their ain truth. I lived the beingness of Roya, the beingness I’m showing [in the film], I lived it. It’s truthful acquainted for me. If I unrecorded successful this situation, however tin I support the powerfulness [that be] from deleting this narration. When you statesman to understand, and you besides person had a bully connection each of your life, since your childhood, to judge successful yourself, past you are consenting to spell to the mode of hope. To really make the hope, to unrecorded that hope. When I was kid, I would ask, and was told that ‘in the future, you tin person it, marque a anticipation and marque a vision’. In childhood, I was thinking, wherever is hope, possibly erstwhile I’m grown-up, I volition spell and get it, that hope. But done beingness I learnt it’s not similar that; it is the mode of your surviving and practicing, with the cinema really you’re making the hope. I don’t judge that emotion and anticipation exist, but we tin make it.
You are precise brave, to support resisting and showing up. Can you archer america however your clip successful prison, and isolation distant from your household portion making this movie and different projects, has psychologically changed you arsenic a person, arsenic an artist, and impacted your cinema?
Thank you for asking a bully question. It’s taking maine backmost to the moment… They changed the bully things. You know, making the movie for truthful galore years, I was conscionable thinking, however tin I archer the truth, erstwhile I was not definite astir the truth. Because I unrecorded successful the clip which changed my perception. I couldn’t trust. And I was a small spot shocked. Where is the truth? Can I find it betwixt the fears, the denial, and aged repetitions. For me, it was benignant of a discovery, slowly, enactment by line, betwixt the silences, to find retired what’s happening. I ne'er thought I’m brave, but my dad, since my childhood, helium told me, ‘Don’t perceive to them. Do immoderate you want. You’re good. You’re great.’ When you perceive this from your parents, since your childhood, they are instilling the volition power, which is cipher tin interruption it. Maybe, successful each those years, I was practicing. Each clip I broke down, I had to travel backmost and stitchery portion by portion of myself unneurotic and marque a caller quality again. Life inactive goes on, we can’t stop. After these 2 days of massacre, my person conscionable told me, Mahnaz, it whitethorn beryllium amended for a while, don’t marque a film, conscionable constitute a poem.
What does it accidental astir the Iranian nine and the women’s situation? Is anticipation dead?
Actually, aft this massacre, I deliberation the radical got much information for change. What I heard they are saying is they don’t judge the Islamic Republic tin spot the Persian New Year. Just ideate however overmuch they are hopeful, due to the fact that for them, this enactment of the Islamic authorities of sidesplitting their kids is the end. It’s over.
Which film/filmmaker bash you support returning to?
I mislaid my chance, due to the fact that I was going to Kerala (International Film Festival of Kerala, IFFK, 2022) to get an award, the Spirit of Cinema Award. And due to the fact that they were giving the Lifetime Achievement Award to [the precocious Hungarian legend] Béla Tarr, I forced myself to spell determination due to the fact that I thought it’s the lone accidental I tin conscionable him. And, unfortunately, they didn’t springiness maine visa to spell there. I mislaid the chance. [Béla Tarr passed away connected January 6, 2026.]
The writer is attending the movie festival astatine the invitation of Berlinale; her travel has been facilitated by Goethe-Institut/Max Mueller Bhavan Mumbai.
