7 months ago
2
The Kerala High Court connected Monday (October 13, 2025) dismissed a nationalist involvement litigation (PIL) filed earlier the tribunal by a lawyer connected September 18, seeking a enactment connected the merchantability of Booker Prize victor Arundhati Roy’s precocious released bookMother Mary Comes To Me, whose screen photograph shows her smoking a beedi.
The lawyer-petitioner had contended that the publication did not person immoderate statutory health-hazard informing statement regarding smoking and that this was a usurpation of Section 5 of the Cigarettes and Other Tobacco Products (Prohibition of Advertisement and Regulation of Trade and Commerce, Production, Supply and Distribution) Act, 2013. Later, it emerged that determination was a written disclaimer regarding the ill-effects of smoking, astatine the backmost of the book.
The screen leafage of the book
While proceeding the petition connected Monday, a Division Bench comprising Chief Justice Nitin Jamdar and Justice Basant Balaji said it was up to the steering committee constituted nether the Act to determine whether the substance was an infringement of Section 5 of the Act, aft proceeding the parties. In this case, the petitioner, contempt being made alert of, has refused to instrumentality up the contented earlier the committee.
He filed the petition without examining the ineligible proviso and without verifying whether determination was a disclaimer mentioned astatine the backmost of the book. In the airy of the circumstances, the petition has been dismissed, keeping successful caput the caution that the tribunal indispensable guarantee PILs are not utilized a conveyance for self-publicity oregon for engaging successful idiosyncratic slander.
The petitioner’s counsel had contended past Tuesday that the disclaimer mentioned astatine the backmost of the publication was insufficient and that it ought to person been published successful a conspicuous manner. He said the photograph sans a disclaimer connected the beforehand leafage had the imaginable to nonstop a misleading connection to impressionable youth, particularly girls and women.
The Centre’s counsel had submitted past that isolated from the steering committee, specified complaints could beryllium registered done an online portal acceptable up nether the nationalist baccy power programme. These options ought to person been tried out, alternatively than straight attack the High Court successful the guise of a PIL.
